My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️
Title: Bloody Black
Author: Rhiannon Hargadon
Format: ebook
Pages: 534
Publication Date: 9/12/25
Categories: Dark Fantasy, Dark Romance, Pirates
He stole her throne, she’s come back to reclaim it.
Anne was a reckless, arrogant royal who had never tasted defeat. After a brutal betrayal on her wedding night, Anne vanishes from the kingdom she was meant to rule. Years later, she’s returns from the grave—no longer a princess, but a terror of the seas. Known only as Blackbeard, she’s hunting down the men who destroyed her, one by one. Vengeance doesn’t come without a cost. Brutal bargains with a demon collar her, and bind her to a dark promise.
When she captures Lieutenant Robb Maynard—a too-handsome, too-calm officer loyal to her enemy—Anne intends to trade him for leverage. Instead, she finds herself locked in a dangerous game of secrets and seduction, where the greatest threat isn’t a blade—but the way he looks at her.
Like she’s still a woman worth loving.
And while she knows better than to believe in anything but pain… Anne must decide if life is worth the risk—or if trusting the wrong man will cost her everything she has built.
A full list of trigger warnings can be found on the author’s website. Your mental health is important; read at your own risk.
Content Warning: rape, sexual assault, murder, violence, death, torture
World Building: I haven’t read a pirate novel in awhile and I picked this up in Kindle Unlimited because of the title and the book cover. Anne was, as princesses go, pretty privileged – to the point her dad let her pick her own groom if she could defeat his soldiers in a tournament. She picks her groom but gets a harsh lesson in love when she realizes she’s made the wrong move. Left for dead, she finds herself on a ship with other prisoners and from there she learns to rule the high seas and make a name for herself as Blackbeard. I loved the pirate adventures and fights that are featured in this story. Anne and her crew travel all over to hunt down her attackers and free people who are enslaved. Would have love to see them rescuing people though since that’s what their mission was all about. Also, Anne’s dad, the king, was a horrible man, but we only get information about that from people he had wronged. I kind of wish this was a duology so we could get more world building.
Characters: Anne isn’t the most likable character but I liked her. She goes through something very traumatic so her fears and anger are ruling her decisions – she is female rage on borrowed time. So I understood her tunnel vision mission of finding her attackers and picking them off one by one. I also didn’t like some of her decisions because of what that fear and rage is doing to her, but it’s part of her growth. I was all in on her revenge tour after what happened to her. I love her crew members full of misfits and different species! Every one had their own issues to deal with, and I didn’t blame Prudence for doing what she did – but it broke my heart. But together, they were all so funny and I was glad Anne had them.
Romance: After what happened to Anne in the beginning of the book I was hoping this would be a slow burn and it was! She’s had trauma and when Robb comes along, he has to learn to be more gentle with her. It is enemies to lovers though, since Robb is hunting Blackbeard. But right away I could tell he was good for her because of his patience. I enjoyed the spice because he was patient with her. He’s kind of a softie when it comes to her. She seems to be the more domineering one in the relationship which I thought was cute. There are some secrets between them though but I was rooting for them!
Story: This is a dark fantasy with many triggering scenes. So definitely check the triggers. I loved how this was a story of Anne’s survival – she had to become someone else, Blackbeard, to help herself feel strong again. But she also had to learn how to be strong again with help and not always pushing people away to be alone. I didn’t mind her hunting her attackers one by one and torturing some of them, I was angry with her. I love how Blackbeard is retold as a woman, and I really did enjoy her crew of pirates.
There were some parts of the writing where I had to read again because a character, will kind of be forgotten. There were a few chapters where one of my favorite secondary characters wasn’t mentioned anymore and I even stopped and wondered where she was. Then she’d reappear again in other chapters.
Vibes: revenge and pirates
Final Thoughts:
Outside all the dark themes of this book, I thought the pirate themes of the book was really fun – especially Anne and her crew. I love them! But as I said, this is a dark book with horrible things that happen to Anne and to the people that wronged her. She’s a person bent on revenge but it consumes her so much that she doesn’t appreciate or know how to be friends with the people that have her back until it’s too late. I enjoyed the romance also but would have loved if this was a duology so we could have had more world-buidling. Other than that though, I enjoyed this retelling of Blackbeard which is full of pirates, some romance and lots of revenge.
Read if you like:
- pirates
- dark romance/dark fantasy
- revenge
Book Links:
Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble
Past Midnight Book Reviews & More 