Shadow Reaper – Past Midnight Book Reviews & More

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Title: Shadow Reaper (#1)

Author: Lynette Noni

Format: eBook (NetGalley)

Pages: 496

Publication Date: 6/16/26

Publisher: Knopf Books for Young Readers

Categories: Young Adult, Fantasy, Romance, Magic, Series

Disclaimer: **I received this book free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.**

Thank you to Knopf Books for Young Readers for giving me a chance to read this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

Never bargain with a reaper.

The city of Aravell is in peril, plagued by a deadly blackmist that kills all it touches and reapers who roam the streets, stealing magic from innocent children in their thirst for power. Seventeen-year-old Viridia Solace has trained for years to hunt these reapers, but their ranks keep growing, led by the man who murdered her parents: the notorious Reaper Priest.

When the Priest’s most loyal follower, Reeve Ashton, is captured, he offers Viri a chance to avenge her parents . . . for a price. She knows better than to bargain with a reaper, let alone this reaper, but his offer is too good to resist.

Soon she’s breaking him out of prison, colluding with his crew of magic thieves, and following him deep into the blackmist forest in search of an ancient legend, all so they can stop the Reaper Priest’s plot to doom the city. Viri is staking her life on Reeve’s plan, but how can she trust a silver-tongued criminal to keep his word? And how can she trust her own heart when a buried secret could shatter everything?

Full of relentless twists, enemies-to-lovers romance, found family, and high stakes action, Shadow Reaper is the start of a breathtaking new duology from international bestselling author Lynette Noni.

Content Warning: violence, death

World Building: This story is set in a city where there is a blackmist that can kill and reapers kidnapping children to siphon magic from them. Hunters like Viri hunt down Reapers, but now she’s onto trying to bring down a bigger player, the Reaper Priest, and there is one reaper who can lead her to him – Reeve, her childhood friend and brother’s best friend. It seems like by the end of this book though, the world will open up in book two to where the reapers live. There is magic but would have liked to learn more about it.

Characters: Viri is a renowned hunter, and she’s hunting down the Reaper Priest with Reeve’s help. I did enjoy their interactions a lot! There are a lot of secondary characters I enjoyed like Viri’s best-friend Wynter, who is like a mad scientist/alchemist – she was fun. And one of Reeve’s friend’s Jonas and his bunny. I did like meeting all these characters and the found family between them.

Romance: There is a romance brewing between Viri and Reeve but it’s not at the forefront of this story. It’s very much in the background with a some moments of them bantering, I just wanted more though. Not sure what will happen to them in book two though.

Story: The first half felt like it dragged, including the chapters with the journal from the celestial mage – it would kind of take me out of the story, though it’s very important to the history of the magic and certain events in this story. I’m not sure why it didn’t interest me. So the pacing for me was off. Things pick up a lot in the second half and there are some secrets and betrayals.

Vibes: Hunters, Reapers, Magic, Betrayal

Final Thoughts:

I didn’t connect to this one as much as I wanted to but I did like the world building and the cast of characters when they were all together. I would have liked a little more romance. The first half was definitely a struggle for me to get through because it moved slow but it picks up in the second half. I enjoyed the secrets and betrayals and look forward to seeing what happens in book two.

Read if you like: