Vices & Virtue by. Alexis L. Menard | ARC and ALC Review

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️

Title: Vices & Virtues

Author: Alexis L. Menard

Pages: 496

Format: audiobook and ebook

Listening Hours: 15 hours (approx.)

Narrator (s): Alex Raby; E.M. Wylde

Publisher: Hachette Audio

Publication Date: 11/24/26

Categories: Fantasy, Romance, Standalone


The Cycle always repeats itself. Why would this one have a different ending?

The Past: Osric Hale lives, steals, and commits all his vices under the ruthless sun of Sol-Trabes. After completing corrupted contracts for good coin, he’s almost saved enough to pay for a new life somewhere else. When his last job goes wrong, he’s tasked with finding a missing Divine with a woman who hates him—or face eternity in a crypt. Everything changes when the job for a lifetime ends in the death of the Sun King. Osric loses his life, the woman he loves, and from his failure, the realm is left stuck in Night.

The Present: Desiree Darrow needs to end the Eternal Night to stop her sister from dying under service to the Night Queen. But to do this, she needs the help of a man who died over a hundred years ago. As a Soul Summoner, she raises Osric Hale from the dead to help her find the Sun King, set his soul free, and restart the Cycle. But old betrayals and secrets are resurrected with him, challenging the path ahead.

As the past and present converge, Des discovers a centuries-old connection between her and Osric, and an ancient evil that has endured just as long. The past repeats itself, but the Cycle must be broken. Desiree and Osric will have to face their greatest sacrifice yet to bring back the Sun.

+ The narrators did a good job with bringing the characters to life. And I’m glad I had the audiobook book because I did find the beginning of this book hard to get into.

+~ There are dual timelines in this story, which I think made it hard for me to get into. But it’s important to push through because the timelines are important to what happens later in the book. In the present timeline, Desiree wants to end the Eternal Night, to save her sister. Des raises Osiric from the dead, he was the one who hunted the Sun King 100 years ago and plunged them into the Eternal Night so she needs his help. But we also follow the timeline in the past where Osiric teams up with Marsala to find the Sun King. I think because the story starts with the present timeline, I was more invested in that timeline and sometimes going back in time would feel so drawn out and for some reason I was bored. But jumping on the audiobook helped so much, I’m glad I had both formats to help me get through this story.

+ All the characters were fascinating but Osiric was probably my favorite because he’s got so much personality. He can be ruthless when fighting but he is a flirt around Marsala and Desiree.

+~ The romance is a slow burn and there are things that happen in the second half of the story that made me think I wouldn’t like how things would play out in the end. But the romance eventually won me over even though it is very bittersweet. It’s quite a love story once you finally see how things do play out.

+~ The world building was fascinating because of the Eternal Night in the present, but it was interesting to see the past and present. Pacing was off for me just because I struggled in the middle of the story to stay invested but I’m glad it picks up at the end.

Final Thoughts:

I have mixed feelings about this one. I enjoyed the beginning, but I struggled through the middle, and then things picked up at the end. The reveals at the end made me love this story more. I thought the world building was fascinating and the romance, though it was such a slow burn, ended up being kind of an epic love story, but a bittersweet one. Overall, I mostly enjoyed this one because of the audiobook.

Read if you like:

  • slow burn romance
  • fantasy
  • past lives

Book Links:

Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble

The Anatomy of Magic by. Alexis L. Menard | Book Review – 4 stars/ 1.5🌶️