I Could Give You the Moon – Past Midnight Book Reviews & More

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

Spice Rating: 🌶️ (closed door)

Title: I Could Give You the Moon

Author: Ann Liang

Narrator(s): Natalie Naudus

Format: audiobook (NetGalley)

Pages: 352 Listening Time: Approximately hours

Publication Date: 4/14/26

Publisher: Harlequin Audio

Categories: Young Adult, Magical Realism, Romance, Suspense

Disclaimer: **I received this book free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.**

Thank you to Harlequin Audio for giving me a chance to read this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

New York Times bestselling author Ann Liang returns to the world of her acclaimed debut, If You Could See the Sun, as a picture-perfect influencer teams up with the bad boy after they share a vision of future.

Everyone loves Chanel Cao—except Ares Yin.

While Chanel has spent her entire life curating a picture-perfect social media personality—from her body to her hair to her camera-ready smile—Ares has spent his trying to hide in the shadows. But Ares’s brother is missing, and Chanel’s parents have secretly separated, and their only hope is each other.

Ares is willing to do whatever it takes to find his brother, and Chanel will do anything to keep her parents’ secret. When the two meet and share a vision of the future—where Ares’s brother appears, as Chanel’s house burns to the ground—they are determined to use each other. Ares believes Chanel is the key to finding his brother, but Chanel is convinced if she gets Ares to fall in love with her, she’ll save her family house—and her parents’ crumbling marriage.

But Ares isn’t interested in the fake personality that Chanel has used her entire life to get affection and adoration. If she’s going to save h

Content Warning: parent cheating, toxic family

+ I requested this one right away after reading If You Could See The Sun, and my goal is to read all the books from this author. I listened to this as an audiobook and so far I’ve listened to this author narrator three books in the span of two weeks and I love her voice! She does such a great job.

+ Chanel is from If You Could See The Sun, she is Alice’s friend – the one who is an influencer, very rich but her dad is caught cheating. She is materialistic, narcissistic, but a good person. Ares is the new boy who doesn’t give her the time of day and they both have a vision, with both of them in it. So Chanel is trying to change the vision because it involves her world burning down – literally. But Ares is so different from all the guys she’s ever known – he has a sense of danger around him, he always has some type of injury because he likes to fight and box. Ares is the best and he is really patient with Chanel’s life style. I loved learning about him.

+ Chanel doesn’t believe in love because of her parents’ marriage and Ares doesn’t come from a great family dynamic either so though they are opposites – they find some things in common, and they closer and closer as they learn more about one another. They both become a safe place for one another which I thought was so sweet. I enjoyed their romance!

+~ Henry does make a cameo in this book more so than Alice does. And though the magical realism worked for me in If You Could See the Sun – it doesn’t quite work for me here in I Could Give You the Moon. There is a vision and Chanel wants to prevent this vision from coming true – but half the time her goal is to become prom queen and have Ares ask her to prom. She thinks if Ares falls in love with her, then he won’t do what she say in the vision. I mean it’s kind of a plan because she’s so confident guys always fall for her but I didn’t believe she could pull it off. I am glad they connect over their toxic families and fall for one another without really meaning to.

Final Thoughts:

I loved the narrator – she did a great job as always. For the most part I enjoyed this story, especially the opposites attract romance, but I did like If You Could See the Sun just a little more because of the rivals to lovers romance. But I think if you like the first book, you will enjoy this one too.