Mayra by. Nicky Gonzalez | ARC Review – Past Midnight Book Reviews & More

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Title: Mayra

Author: Nicky Gonzalez

Format: eBook (NetGalley)

Pages: 240

Publication Date: 7/22/25

Publisher: Random House

Categories: Suspense, Mystery, Contemporary

Disclaimer: **I received this book free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.**

Thank you to Random House for giving me a chance to read this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

An eerie, hypnotic debut about friendship, desire, and memory set against the sultry backdrop of Florida’s swamplands

It’s been years since Ingrid has heard from her childhood best friend, Mayra, a fearless rebel who fled their hometown of Hialeah, a Cuban neighborhood just west of Miami, for college in the Northeast. But when Mayra calls out of the blue to invite Ingrid to a weekend getaway at a house in the Everglades, she impulsively accepts.

From the moment Ingrid sets out for the house, danger looms: The directions are difficult, she’s out of reach of cell service, and as she drives deeper into the Everglades, the wet maw of the swamp threatens to swallow her whole. But once Ingrid arrives, Mayra is, in many ways, just as she remembers—with her sharp tongue and effortless, seductive beauty, still thumbing her nose at the world.

Before they can fully settle into the familiar intimacy of each other’s company, their reunion is spoiled by the reemergence of past disagreements and the unexpected presence of Mayra’s new boyfriend, Benji. The trio spend their hours eating lavish meals and exploring the labyrinthine house, which holds as much mystery and danger as the swamp itself. Indoors and on the grounds, time itself seems to expand, and Ingrid begins to lose a sense of the outside world, and herself.

Against this disquieting setting, where lizards dart in and out of porches and alligators peek up from dark waters, Gonzalez weaves a surreal, unforgettable story about the dizzying power of early friendship and the lengths we’ll go to earn love and acceptance—even at the risk of losing ourselves entirely.

Content Warning:

+ I am not the right audience for this book. But I still found myself intrigued with the story.

+ My favorite part of the book is the atmosphere, the Florida swamp, and how isolated and lost you can get. I think the author did such a great job setting the scene. Also I liked Ingrid’s voice – she’s a very fleshed out character so even though nothing much was happening for half way into the book, I liked her stories about her early years with Mayra.

+ The friendship between Ingrid and Mayra is a big part of this story and actually it seemed like that’s all this story was about. How a close friendship can change, what the person means to you and other themes of friendship. I like how that was explored, especially with both girls being Cuban and how they were raised was very different from, Mayra’s boyfriend-Benji’s upbringing.

+ This is a short book, under 300 pages and nothing much happens in it until near the end when some of the secret of the house they are staying at is revealed.

~ I wanted to learn more about the sentient house, but once we find out what’s happening the story ends.

~ I don’t think I grasped what the book was about – except for Ingrid and Mayra’s relationship and how they were when they were younger, to now together in the house where things are happening, like making them forget, keeping them there without them really noticing.

~ Ingrid finding a journal halfway through the book? It didn’t interest me and I couldn’t see how that connected with what was happening at first. Until of course the secret of the house is kind of revealed but by then the story was over.

Final Thoughts:

This wasn’t for me but I did enjoy the atmosphere, Ingrid and Mayra. I do wish we learned about what was happening in the house much earlier in the story but I guess there were subtle hints that went totally over my head since Ingrid and Mayra’s friendship was the focus. Would have loved more horror but there wasn’t any really. I think if you like atmospheric mystery and suspense you might enjoy this one.