Harlot’s Bay – Past Midnight Book Reviews & More

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

Spice: 🌶️🌶️

Title: Second Chance Romance (Harlot’s Bay, #2)

Author: Olivia Dade

Format: ebook (borrowed – Libby)

Pages: 395

Publication Date: 11/25/25

Categories: Contemporary, Romance, Second Chance Romance

In the second installment of USA Today bestselling author Olivia Dade’s Harlot’s Bay series, a mistaken obituary leads to the reunion of two former high school crushes. Sparks fly in this hilarious grumpy/grumpy romance, packed with Dade’s signature body positivity and a delicious amount of spice.

Karl and Molly were never together. There was a time, right after high school, where it seemed like they might finally cross the line from friends to lovers…but instead, a foolish misunderstanding meant they never spoke again. Molly went to LA and got married. Karl stayed in Harlot’s Bay and bought a bakery.

The only connection the pair has shared over the years is painfully one-sided: Now divorced, Molly narrates monster romance audiobooks, and Karl is an ever-diligent listener, clinging to his only piece of the one that got away.

Still, Molly hasn’t totally left Harlot’s Bay behind. When she hears that Karl’s obituary has run in the local paper, unexpected grief prompts her to hop on the next flight to Maryland…where she finds Karl very much alive, the victim of nothing but an accidental obituary.

As the pair reunite, they finally hash out their missed connection. True, Molly isn’t quite ready to trust again, but Karl is determined to prove himself worthy of her faith and devotion. And as her remaining time in Harlot’s Bay ticks down, Molly, the habitual cynic, just might find that Karl, the cranky town curmudgeon, is impossible to leave behind a second time.

Content Warning:

I didn’t read book one in this series, but I wanted to try out an Olivia Dade book and this caught my eye so I borrowed it.

+ Harlot’s Bay is a small town, one that Molly wants to eventually escape. We get to see how Molly and Karl evolve as friends in high school to how they fell apart and reconnect again. I love the setting of Harlot’s Bay – the community seems wholesome yet quirky, and Karl is a staple there with his bakery. Molly does escape to California, and she comes back to Hartlot’s Bay due to a misunderstanding which I thought was funny.

+ Both Karl and Molly are strong characters, they know who they are, which is refreshing. Karl is grumpy, swears a lot, but he’s a good guy who just wants Molly. He goes out of his way to try and make her feel comfortable, build trust in him, and gives her time even though he stubbornly wants her to move back to Harlot’s Bay. Molly is someone who doesn’t trust easily because of her father. She’s been married and divorced and still has to deal with her ex. But I love how she’s an audiobook narrator! And the fact that Karl listened to the smutty books and was a fan was so funny and cute. These two are quite a couple and they just work!

+ The romance was cute – Karl asks Molly to stay until the school reunion and give him a chance. Karl isn’t the type to know how to express his feelings, he’s grumpy, but he and Molly completed one another because she can be grumpy too. They try to build trust between one another by going on dates and doing trust exercises. I love how he gave her space and time. But one thing is undeniable, there are lots of sparks between them, so things do get spicy.

+ There is a little bit of romance. Lucan is the Vicar’s adopted son, and he’s been tasked to keep his eye on Isola. Isola doesn’t like him because an incident in the past, but during the Tribunal, they spend more time with one another and decide to team up. Being around one another makes their attraction grow. I was definitely rooting for Lucan and Isola but we’ll have to see what happens in book two.

~ They both had communication issues, so I didn’t finish this as quick as I thought I would because they were taking so long to communicate how they feel.

Final Thoughts:

I mostly enjoyed this one but I did take longer to finish this – I really thought I could finish it in three days, but I think the trust exercises and lack of communication took me out of the story a little bit. But I did love the Harlot’s Bay community, there are so many fun character and funny moments. I also like the plus-size representation and though Karl and Molly had communication issues, he really was in love with her and would do anything to make her stay. I loved that about him! I’ll definitely try out more books from this author.