Chinese Fantasy – Past Midnight Book Reviews & More

My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

Spice Rating:

Title: Never Ever After (#1)

Author: Sue Lynn Tan

Format: hardcover (own)

Pages: 368

Publication Date: 10/28/25

Categories: Chinese Fantasy, Romance, Romantasy, Young Adult, Series

Not all fairy tales end happily ever after in this Cinderella-inspired fantasy by the bestselling author of Daughter of the Moon Goddess.

Yining stopped believing in dreams the day her beloved uncle died. Driven to survive, she’s become a good thief and an even better liar. When she acquires an enchanted ring that could yield the key to a better life, it is stolen by her grasping stepaunt, and Yining must venture into the imperial heart of the Iron Mountains to seize it back.
Amid the grandeur of the palace, Yining catches the eye of the ruthless and ambitious Prince Zixin, who tempts her with a world she’s never imagined. But nothing is as it seems as she’s soon trapped in a tangle of power, treachery, and greed-her only ally a cunning advisor from a rival court who keeps dangerous secrets of his own. Desperate to secure her freedom, Yining embarks on a perilous quest where she must choose who to trust, unravel the mystery of her past, and fight for a future that both frightens and calls to her.

Content Warning: violence, death, animal death

+ The beginning of this fantasy book is Cinderella-inspired for sure. Yining is a young woman who is surviving as a thief under the guardianship of her step-aunt. Her Uncle was the one who took care of her but when he dies, she ends up with her step-aunt, who is always getting in trouble. But one day Yining comes across a magic carp who gives her a wooden ring, a gift, from her mom who she never knew. Yining isn’t supposed to take off the ring but an incident happens where it does come off – the thief being her aunt and she attends the Prince’s ball to find her aunt and the ring. But this Cinderella story has a big twist, where the Prince isn’t exactly charming.

+~ Though I did like how this story started, I do think the beginning moved a little slow as we try to figure out Prince Zixin’s personality and motivations. He seems like a charming prince, but then Yining finds out more about him and her mind changes. On the other hand there is Jin who is part of the envoy from Thorn Valley. Yining strikes a bargain with him to get her ring back from the prince. I did enjoy the second half of the story where there is more action, and we learn about Yining’s mysterious past. I enjoyed the political intrigue happening between the different kingdoms.

+ This looks a love triangle is brewing. Jin and Yining get close, but can she trust him? Then she finds out something about the Prince that can’t make her totally hate him, but I don’t know why at the end it felt like something could be explored between them too? I’m glad it doesn’t end with either guy because there is more to explore about Yining and her past. But it will be interesting to see which guy comes out the winner in her eyes.

~ I’m sure this will be more explored in book two but it would be nice to have more information about the magic. And I think that will all happen on Mist Island, or at least I hope. Because there are many magical elements in this story, a magic carp, a dragon, nature magic, but I don’t feel like we get to know much about it in this book, so hopefully we get it in the next one.

Final Thoughts:

Overall, I thought pacing was an issue and I loved the second half more than the first off. Starting off as a Cindrerella-inspired story was intriguing but the story changes and soon it doesn’t resemble the fairy tale at all. I enjoyed the political intrigue and even the love triangle because I can’t tell who Yining will choose in the end. I’d love to learn more about the magic system so I hope we can get that in book two.

Read if you like: